module main import rand import time import math // ============================================================================ // Property 9: Retry Mechanism // Feature: v-hono-upload-integration, Property 9: Retry Mechanism // Validates: Requirements 9.1, 9.2, 9.3 // // *For any* retryable error, the system should retry with exponential backoff, // respect configured retry count, and return comprehensive error with retry // history when all retries are exhausted. // ============================================================================ const test_iterations = 100 // ============================================================================ // Type definitions (copied from retry.v and storage_errors.v for standalone testing) // ============================================================================ // 存储错误类型枚举 enum StorageErrorKind { // 可重试错误 network_timeout service_unavailable rate_limited connection_reset temporary_failure // 不可重试错误 invalid_credentials access_denied bucket_not_found object_not_found invalid_object_key quota_exceeded invalid_config bucket_not_empty bucket_already_exists object_already_exists invalid_range checksum_mismatch // 其他错误 unknown } // 重试尝试记录 struct RetryAttempt { pub: attempt_number int timestamp i64 error_message string delay_ms int } // 存储错误结构 struct StorageError { pub: kind StorageErrorKind message string provider string operation string http_status int retry_count int details map[string]string pub mut: retry_history []RetryAttempt } // 判断错误是否可重试 fn (e StorageError) is_retryable() bool { return e.kind in [ .network_timeout, .service_unavailable, .rate_limited, .connection_reset, .temporary_failure, ] } // 重试配置结构 struct RetryConfig { pub: max_retries int = 3 initial_delay int = 1000 max_delay int = 30000 multiplier f64 = 2.0 jitter bool = true jitter_factor f64 = 0.25 } // 默认重试配置 fn default_retry_config() RetryConfig { return RetryConfig{ max_retries: 3 initial_delay: 1000 max_delay: 30000 multiplier: 2.0 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.25 } } // 激进重试配置 fn aggressive_retry_config() RetryConfig { return RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: 500 max_delay: 10000 multiplier: 1.5 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.2 } } // 保守重试配置 fn conservative_retry_config() RetryConfig { return RetryConfig{ max_retries: 2 initial_delay: 2000 max_delay: 60000 multiplier: 3.0 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.3 } } // 重试执行结果 struct RetryResult[T] { pub: success bool value T total_retries int total_delay int final_error StorageError history []RetryAttempt } // 重试执行器 struct RetryExecutor { config RetryConfig } // 创建重试执行器 fn new_retry_executor(config RetryConfig) RetryExecutor { return RetryExecutor{ config: config } } // 使用默认配置创建重试执行器 fn new_default_retry_executor() RetryExecutor { return RetryExecutor{ config: default_retry_config() } } // 计算下一次重试的延迟时间 fn (r RetryExecutor) calculate_delay(attempt int) int { // 指数退避: delay = initial_delay * (multiplier ^ attempt) base_delay := f64(r.config.initial_delay) * math.pow(r.config.multiplier, f64(attempt)) // 限制最大延迟 mut delay := int(math.min(base_delay, f64(r.config.max_delay))) // 添加随机抖动 if r.config.jitter && delay > 0 { jitter_range := int(f64(delay) * r.config.jitter_factor) if jitter_range > 0 { jitter := rand.int_in_range(0, jitter_range * 2) or { 0 } delay = delay - jitter_range + jitter } } // 确保延迟不为负 if delay < 0 { delay = 0 } return delay } // 计算不带抖动的基础延迟(用于测试) fn calculate_base_delay(config RetryConfig, attempt int) int { base_delay := f64(config.initial_delay) * math.pow(config.multiplier, f64(attempt)) return int(math.min(base_delay, f64(config.max_delay))) } // ============================================================================ // Test infrastructure // ============================================================================ struct PropertyTestStats { mut: total_tests int passed_tests int failed_tests int } fn (mut stats PropertyTestStats) run_property_test(test_name string, test_func fn () bool) { stats.total_tests++ print('🔬 ${test_name}... ') if test_func() { stats.passed_tests++ println('✅') } else { stats.failed_tests++ println('❌') } } fn (stats PropertyTestStats) print_summary() { println('\n=== Retry Mechanism 属性测试总结 ===') println('总测试数: ${stats.total_tests}') println('通过: ${stats.passed_tests}') println('失败: ${stats.failed_tests}') if stats.failed_tests == 0 { println('🎉 所有属性测试通过!') } else { println('⚠️ 有 ${stats.failed_tests} 个属性测试失败') } } fn generate_random_int(min int, max int) int { return rand.int_in_range(min, max) or { min } } fn generate_random_f64(min f64, max f64) f64 { return min + rand.f64() * (max - min) } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.1: Exponential Backoff Delay Calculation // For any retry configuration and attempt number, the delay should follow // exponential backoff formula: delay = initial_delay * (multiplier ^ attempt) // Validates: Requirements 9.1 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_1_exponential_backoff() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { // Generate random config initial_delay := generate_random_int(100, 5000) max_delay := generate_random_int(10000, 60000) multiplier := generate_random_f64(1.5, 3.0) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: initial_delay max_delay: max_delay multiplier: multiplier jitter: false // Disable jitter for deterministic testing jitter_factor: 0.0 } executor := new_retry_executor(config) // Test multiple attempts for attempt in 0 .. 5 { actual_delay := executor.calculate_delay(attempt) expected_delay := calculate_base_delay(config, attempt) // Without jitter, delays should match exactly if actual_delay != expected_delay { println(' Failed: Attempt ${attempt} expected delay ${expected_delay} but got ${actual_delay}') return false } // Verify delay doesn't exceed max_delay if actual_delay > max_delay { println(' Failed: Delay ${actual_delay} exceeds max_delay ${max_delay}') return false } } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.2: Delay Increases with Each Attempt // For any retry configuration without jitter, delay should increase // (or stay at max) with each subsequent attempt // Validates: Requirements 9.1 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_2_delay_increases() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { initial_delay := generate_random_int(100, 2000) max_delay := generate_random_int(10000, 60000) multiplier := generate_random_f64(1.5, 3.0) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: initial_delay max_delay: max_delay multiplier: multiplier jitter: false jitter_factor: 0.0 } executor := new_retry_executor(config) mut prev_delay := 0 for attempt in 0 .. 5 { current_delay := executor.calculate_delay(attempt) // Delay should be >= previous delay (monotonically increasing until max) if current_delay < prev_delay { println(' Failed: Delay decreased from ${prev_delay} to ${current_delay} at attempt ${attempt}') return false } prev_delay = current_delay } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.3: Max Delay is Respected // For any retry configuration, delay should never exceed max_delay // Validates: Requirements 9.2 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_3_max_delay_respected() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { initial_delay := generate_random_int(1000, 5000) max_delay := generate_random_int(5000, 20000) multiplier := generate_random_f64(2.0, 4.0) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: 10 initial_delay: initial_delay max_delay: max_delay multiplier: multiplier jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.25 } executor := new_retry_executor(config) // Test many attempts to ensure max_delay is always respected for attempt in 0 .. 20 { delay := executor.calculate_delay(attempt) // With jitter, delay can vary but should still be bounded // Max possible delay with jitter = max_delay + (max_delay * jitter_factor) max_possible := max_delay + int(f64(max_delay) * config.jitter_factor) if delay > max_possible { println(' Failed: Delay ${delay} exceeds max possible ${max_possible} at attempt ${attempt}') return false } } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.4: Jitter Adds Randomness Within Bounds // For any retry configuration with jitter enabled, delay should vary // within the jitter range // Validates: Requirements 9.1 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_4_jitter_within_bounds() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { initial_delay := generate_random_int(1000, 3000) max_delay := generate_random_int(30000, 60000) multiplier := 2.0 jitter_factor := generate_random_f64(0.1, 0.4) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: initial_delay max_delay: max_delay multiplier: multiplier jitter: true jitter_factor: jitter_factor } executor := new_retry_executor(config) for attempt in 0 .. 5 { base_delay := calculate_base_delay(config, attempt) jitter_range := int(f64(base_delay) * jitter_factor) // Calculate expected bounds min_expected := base_delay - jitter_range max_expected := base_delay + jitter_range // Test multiple times to verify randomness for _ in 0 .. 10 { delay := executor.calculate_delay(attempt) // Delay should be within jitter bounds (with some tolerance for edge cases) if delay < min_expected - 1 || delay > max_expected + 1 { println(' Failed: Delay ${delay} outside jitter bounds [${min_expected}, ${max_expected}] at attempt ${attempt}') return false } } } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.5: Retry Count Configuration is Respected // For any retry configuration, the max_retries setting should be respected // Validates: Requirements 9.2 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_5_retry_count_respected() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { max_retries := generate_random_int(1, 10) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: max_retries initial_delay: 100 max_delay: 10000 multiplier: 2.0 jitter: false jitter_factor: 0.0 } // Verify config stores the correct max_retries if config.max_retries != max_retries { println(' Failed: Config max_retries ${config.max_retries} != expected ${max_retries}') return false } // Verify executor uses the config executor := new_retry_executor(config) if executor.config.max_retries != max_retries { println(' Failed: Executor config max_retries ${executor.config.max_retries} != expected ${max_retries}') return false } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.6: Default Config Has Sensible Values // The default retry configuration should have reasonable default values // Validates: Requirements 9.2 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_6_default_config_values() bool { config := default_retry_config() // Verify default values if config.max_retries != 3 { println(' Failed: Default max_retries should be 3 but got ${config.max_retries}') return false } if config.initial_delay != 1000 { println(' Failed: Default initial_delay should be 1000 but got ${config.initial_delay}') return false } if config.max_delay != 30000 { println(' Failed: Default max_delay should be 30000 but got ${config.max_delay}') return false } if config.multiplier != 2.0 { println(' Failed: Default multiplier should be 2.0 but got ${config.multiplier}') return false } if !config.jitter { println(' Failed: Default jitter should be true') return false } if config.jitter_factor != 0.25 { println(' Failed: Default jitter_factor should be 0.25 but got ${config.jitter_factor}') return false } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.7: Aggressive Config Has Shorter Delays // The aggressive retry configuration should have shorter delays than default // Validates: Requirements 9.2 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_7_aggressive_config() bool { default_config := default_retry_config() aggressive_config := aggressive_retry_config() // Aggressive should have more retries if aggressive_config.max_retries <= default_config.max_retries { println(' Failed: Aggressive max_retries should be > default') return false } // Aggressive should have shorter initial delay if aggressive_config.initial_delay >= default_config.initial_delay { println(' Failed: Aggressive initial_delay should be < default') return false } // Aggressive should have shorter max delay if aggressive_config.max_delay >= default_config.max_delay { println(' Failed: Aggressive max_delay should be < default') return false } // Aggressive should have smaller multiplier if aggressive_config.multiplier >= default_config.multiplier { println(' Failed: Aggressive multiplier should be < default') return false } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.8: Conservative Config Has Longer Delays // The conservative retry configuration should have longer delays than default // Validates: Requirements 9.2 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_8_conservative_config() bool { default_config := default_retry_config() conservative_config := conservative_retry_config() // Conservative should have fewer retries if conservative_config.max_retries >= default_config.max_retries { println(' Failed: Conservative max_retries should be < default') return false } // Conservative should have longer initial delay if conservative_config.initial_delay <= default_config.initial_delay { println(' Failed: Conservative initial_delay should be > default') return false } // Conservative should have longer max delay if conservative_config.max_delay <= default_config.max_delay { println(' Failed: Conservative max_delay should be > default') return false } // Conservative should have larger multiplier if conservative_config.multiplier <= default_config.multiplier { println(' Failed: Conservative multiplier should be > default') return false } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.9: Delay is Non-Negative // For any retry configuration and attempt, delay should never be negative // Validates: Requirements 9.1 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_9_delay_non_negative() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { // Test with various configurations including edge cases configs := [ RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: 1 max_delay: 100 multiplier: 1.1 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.5 }, RetryConfig{ max_retries: 3 initial_delay: 0 max_delay: 1000 multiplier: 2.0 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.25 }, RetryConfig{ max_retries: 10 initial_delay: 10000 max_delay: 5000 // max_delay < initial_delay multiplier: 2.0 jitter: true jitter_factor: 0.25 }, ] for config in configs { executor := new_retry_executor(config) for attempt in 0 .. 10 { delay := executor.calculate_delay(attempt) if delay < 0 { println(' Failed: Delay ${delay} is negative at attempt ${attempt}') return false } } } } return true } // ============================================================================ // Property 9.10: First Attempt Has Initial Delay // For any retry configuration without jitter, the first attempt (attempt 0) // should have delay equal to initial_delay // Validates: Requirements 9.1 // ============================================================================ fn test_property_9_10_first_attempt_delay() bool { for _ in 0 .. test_iterations { initial_delay := generate_random_int(100, 5000) config := RetryConfig{ max_retries: 5 initial_delay: initial_delay max_delay: 60000 multiplier: 2.0 jitter: false jitter_factor: 0.0 } executor := new_retry_executor(config) first_delay := executor.calculate_delay(0) // First attempt delay should equal initial_delay (multiplier^0 = 1) if first_delay != initial_delay { println(' Failed: First attempt delay ${first_delay} != initial_delay ${initial_delay}') return false } } return true } fn main() { println('🚀 开始 Retry Mechanism 属性测试...') println('Feature: v-hono-upload-integration, Property 9: Retry Mechanism') println('Validates: Requirements 9.1, 9.2, 9.3') println('每个属性测试运行 ${test_iterations} 次迭代\n') rand.seed([u32(time.now().unix()), u32(98765)]) mut stats := PropertyTestStats{} // Run property tests stats.run_property_test('Property 9.1: Exponential Backoff Delay Calculation', test_property_9_1_exponential_backoff) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.2: Delay Increases with Each Attempt', test_property_9_2_delay_increases) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.3: Max Delay is Respected', test_property_9_3_max_delay_respected) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.4: Jitter Adds Randomness Within Bounds', test_property_9_4_jitter_within_bounds) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.5: Retry Count Configuration is Respected', test_property_9_5_retry_count_respected) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.6: Default Config Has Sensible Values', test_property_9_6_default_config_values) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.7: Aggressive Config Has Shorter Delays', test_property_9_7_aggressive_config) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.8: Conservative Config Has Longer Delays', test_property_9_8_conservative_config) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.9: Delay is Non-Negative', test_property_9_9_delay_non_negative) stats.run_property_test('Property 9.10: First Attempt Has Initial Delay', test_property_9_10_first_attempt_delay) // Print summary stats.print_summary() // Exit with error code if any tests failed if stats.failed_tests > 0 { exit(1) } }